Friday, 8 March 2024

Book Review - 'Witch Hazel' by Molly Idle

'But is it magic making memories... or are memories making magic?' - from the blurb.


'Witch Hazel' is one of the most unique children's picture books I have ever read. It is about telling stories, and the passage of time; told mostly though pictures.

Stories can be told anywhere, from a front porch, to a music room by a piano.

There's nothing overtly witchy about 'Witch Hazel', no obvious spell casting, but an elderly woman telling of her past to an eager young girl, to keep in her heart forever and learn lessons from the old, is its own kind of wonderful magic. The magic of generations of women, spinning true yarns.

It's an amazing creation. Whimsical and adorable - with the artwork reminiscent of that of 1950s Harvey Comics (think Casper) - and sweet and sad by the end. The cycle of life continues as it always does.

'Witch Hazel' is a lovely darling of a picture book. For its understated witchy regalia of a broom - for sweeping dust from the porch and from a cobwebbed mind - a top hat, and a black cat, its real magic lies in its storytelling power. Memories passed on to the next generation are the true sparkle.

While I wish it were made clearer that the old woman Hazel and the young girl Hilda are grandmother and granddaughter, it doesn't matter much. Their love and devotion to one another is sublimely drawn and presented on every spellbinding page.

What a surprising, bonny and beautiful bustle of memory magic. Like a sad, twinkling fairy tale book of old. 'Witch Hazel' by Molly Idle is something special, to be sure.

Final Score: 4/5

Tuesday, 5 March 2024

Book Review - 'Marnie Midnight and the Moon Mystery' by Laura Ellen Anderson

Marnie Midnight.

Marnie Midnight.

Marnie Midnight the moth.

Marnie Midnight the moth who is obsessed with the moon and moon magic.



Oh, sorry. I had thought about writing this review in the form of a poem or a rap - there are oh so many words that rhyme with Midnight - but I'm not good at that sort of thing, so I'll spare you that slather of word dung and just be straightforward with my thoughts on 'Marnie Midnight and the Moon Mystery':

What a cute, funny, ludicrous, charming, and quick book for children that can be buzzed through in a day. Bugs, the crescent moon, and moon magic - yes, please!

It is rather like a bug-themed version of Laura Ellen Anderson's other book (and series), 'Rainbow Grey'. They both have wide-eyed, enthusiastic young female protagonists, who idolise a much older, female seasoned pioneering explorer and researcher (whom nobody else is a fan of), and who go to an esteemed academy based around their species (with all the creativity that goes with that specifically-themed premise), and have two best friends - an effeminate, fussy boy and a more aggressive, impulsive, go-getter girl - and together the child trio break school rules to go out into the wider world on their own to solve a big mystery that could potentially endanger their own world and people.

(Some of these tropes and templates are similar to 'Amelia Fang', come to think of it.)

While 'Marnie Midnight' isn't as exciting as 'Rainbow Grey', nor are the stakes as high, it still manages to be enjoyable on its own termite, turfy terms. There are plot holes, forgotten plot points, and loads of characters that are introduced and then completely dropped from the story just as quickly (they are sure to feature more prominently in the sequels), but it does have its fun and humorous elements and moments.

Spoiler-free examples include: Marnie the moth, with her love for the moon (same!) and her red jumper knitted for her by her dad; the fabulous (and nosy parker) Floyd Flombiddium the half-bee/half-ladybird (?), called an "A"; Star Vonstrosity the tiny ant, who is a war princess with the personality of Wednesday Addams; travels in/on snails and slugs...and mammals; a ladybird with square spots; a mean girl butterfly trio named Veronica, Thelma and Louise (...I really don't get why that reference is here...seriously, why? 
The film is one of my favourites, but still...someone help me! I'm losing my mind!); champion earthworm bodybuilders--er, burrowers; shifty flies from the "bad part" of a dustbin; a forbidden Moon Club at the very top of Minibeast Academy (the kids' boarding school); and of course, a bit of the mysterious and mythical moon magic, with its own Book of Spells, that's on the moon itself!

Charming, creative, funny and giggly - and thoughtful and loving - little things like these are what make 'Marnie Midnight' a special, somewhat guilty pleasure of mine. There's not a dull page in this addictive, zippeddy-zip book. It's utterly bonkers, and it embraces how bonkers it is. This line exists within it: "I'M TOO BURLY TO DIIIIIIIIE!" Plus there's a moment of self-awareness where Floyd points out that the very beginning of the school term is too early for any of them to already be solving a mystery and having an adventure. Indeed, it seems like the whole book takes place in the span of a few days!

One difference it has from 'Rainbow Grey' is that Marnie first meets Floyd and Star upon approaching and entering Minibeast Academy, instead of them already being friends from the start. Oh, and I'd thought that the little green caterpillar on the cover of 'Marnie Midnight' would be Marnie's cute and annoying pet and sidekick - it turns out he's her younger brother, Milo, and after a cute, humorous goodbye as she leaves for the academy for the first time at the end of chapter three, he disappears from the rest of the book. He's one of many characters who get swatted away by the narrative. Why is he on the cover, then? For extra cuteness attraction? How misleading.

Additionally, there's an anti-racism, myth-busting, and tolerance message, which is very nice and appreciated.

('Rainbow Grey' and 'Amelia Fang' contain themes and lessons exactly like these as well...)

Finally, I like that Floyd is implied to be dyslexic, and have anxiety (and is autistic?).

Read 'Marnie Midnight and the Moon Mystery' for a fun time for an afternoon, and possibly night, when hopefully a crescent moon will be waxing (and polishing and shining brightly).

Now, I must flutter off tonight, when the moon magic will be good.

Final Score: 3.5/5

Monday, 4 March 2024

Book Review - 'I Can Catch a Monster' by Bethan Woollvin

A cool, cute, adventurous, entertaining and quick picture book about a pink-haired action fantasy girl, Bo, who is told by her two brothers that she can't go out to fight monsters with them because she's too small - or it could really be because she's a girl - and who on her quest, motivated by anger and toxic masculinity, learns to listen to and help out "monsters" instead of hunting them, as is the tradition.

Who are the real monsters here?

The not-judging-and-not-killing-those-who-are-different-from-you-and-who-live-outside-of-you-and-your-home message is, of course, important as always, and is surprising to see from the same author as 'Three Little Vikings', which seems to tell the opposite.

I recommend and rank 'I Can Catch a Monster' (also known as 'Bo the Brave') higher than 'Three Little Vikings'. Among other reasons, I'm partial to heroines with pink hair. To action fantasy heroines with pink hair. So sue me.

Final Score: 3.5/5

Graphic Novel Review - 'Stories of the Islands' by Clar Angkasa

What lovely stories! What lovely feminist retellings/reimaginings of previously unheard of (by me) fairy tales! This time the folklore originates from Indonesia.

There are three of them, told and drawn softly and lovingly in graphic novel form - 'Keong Mas', about an unlikely female friendship (possibly more...?), 'Bawang Merah Bawang Putih', about two (step)sisters, and 'Timun Mas', about a mother and a daughter, albeit adopted, and is no less beautiful.

The subversion to traditional fairy tale conventions and archetypes, particularly in female roles, is strong in this.

The leads in 'Stories of the Islands' are far from damsels in distress, yet none of them have to be the equally typical "strong female character" or action heroine to achieve their happily ever after.

The art is so sweet, colourful, round, comfy, creamy, silky, expressive, with lots of shadow work, and gorgeous - the book truly has the feminine touch all around and about it. The soft, pretty colours! 'Stories of the Islands' really is in the same genetic-no, cosmic, nebulous, Milky Way pool as 'Other Ever Afters' by Melanie Gillman. It is like an aurora, abloom with three rich fairy tales, presented to us as a magical graphic novel.

Themes include redemption, humbleness, kindness, giving, charity, helping others out of the goodness of one's heart, grief, domestic abuse, sisterhood, motherhood, spinsterhood, solitude, witchcraft, learning and passing on skills and putting them to use in life (and in life and death situations), and overcoming adversity and evil. These wonderous, wonderful stories with wonderful, soulful, adorable characters - the darn-near-entirely-female cast of characters - are, in fact, universal, and anyone can relate to them.

There are also fish, snails, plants, flowers, seeds, pumpkins, cucumbers, sarongs, selendangs, and of course, the Indonesian islands from ancient historic times these tales take place in.

'Stories of the Islands' - a passion project that paid off. I adore it, as short and limited in number as the stories are. They will stay with you, along with their important messages.

Hope, and hope for serenity, and an inspiring beauty, that is 'Stories of the Islands', written and drawn by Clar Angkasa. Wholeheartedly created, and guaranteed to whole your heart upon reading it, then embracing it.

From the Author's Note at the end:


'Stories of the Islands is a response to questions I'm constantly asking:

Who are these women beyond the hero's love interests? What are their hopes and dreams outside of what's expected of them? Why are they waiting for their saviors instead of just saving themselves?


[...] I have a strong distaste for narratives that perpetuate the concept that a woman is limited to what society expects of them.

[...] I reimaged these folktales in a way I wish they were told to me when I was growing up. I want young girls to be exposed to a different kind of narrative, and be encouraged to break from stereotypes and the pattern of constantly being looked down on and underappreciated.'


Final Score: 4/5

Saturday, 2 March 2024

Graphic Novel Review - 'Cross My Heart and Never Lie' by Nora DÃ¥snes, Matt Bagguley (Translator)

'Cross My Heart and Never Lie' is a sweet and gentle coming-of-age, slice-of-life graphic novel for children and teenagers. It is about the lives of contemporary twelve-year-olds, and is set in Norway, but because the struggles of adolescence are universal, it could be set anywhere in the world.

Join Tuva as she records everything, in writing and in art, in her new diary, from August to October, where she navigates: a new grade at school; her two best friends Bao and Linnéa suddenly being distant and breaking up over newfound, differing interests; the pressure to fall in love and get a boyfriend; the pressure to be "mature" and not be "childish" and play in the woods (or the "bog") during breaks anymore; the pressure to be "cool"; the pressure to wear makeup; getting her first bra when she isn't sure she needs one yet; feeling the need to hide her feelings and keep secrets from her loving single dad (he is awesome, not to mention environmentally conscious); and unexpectedly having a crush on a new girl, Mariam, at school.

Music (she plays the clarinet (wants to play saxophone) in the school marching band) and music playlists also play a major part in Tuva's life. She loves lasagna as much as Garfield, too!

'Cross My Heart and Never Lie' is all about growing up and dealing with changes. It is a graphic novel that any kid would be happy, proud and relieved to own. It is adorable, wholesome, friendly but not dishonest and unrealistic, and pink, blue and yellow (and green, as well). It is what young people in today's world needs. Influencers, specifically those that give makeup tutorials and dating advice on YouTube, are a thing here.

Oh, goddess. Everything feels like the end of the world when you're that young, doesn't it? I can't imagine what it must be like for them nowadays. I dread to try.

Never stop being young, people! Your life will never be over, not while you are still living it, especially if you really are still young, whether you're twelve or in your thirties. Never rush things! You can "mature" personality-wise anytime you want, and be yourself! Adulthood and maturity are mostly made up social constructs, anyway. They're just numbers, yearly cycles. Be responsible, kind, caring and loving, and keep learning things, as always.

'Cross My Heart and Never Lie' - a nice, warm, beautiful, touching, life-affirming tea and candy break of a book.



'Things I want to do in seventh grade:

1. Write (or draw!!) a whole diary

2. Get a cool look (Goals)

3. Build the best base in the Bog with Bao and Linnéa

4. Go to a sleepover birthday party (Stay up late!)

5. Fall in Love (maybe)
'


'Mariam seems really cool... and nice... and we have SO MUCH in common. Well, two things at least. But it feels like more. I don't think ever met someone I wanted to be friends with so badly!
Is that what soul mates are?
Soul mate
(Dad thinks anything to do with souls is stupid, but I think it's nice. Magical, almost.)
'


'I never know what to say. This whole boyfriend situation has become such a BIG THING. And it's not just boyfriends anymore either. You have to decide what group you belong to:
Girls who fall in love OR Girls who NEVER fall in love.
'


'a PERFECT Saturday
Now I'm sitting on the sofa, writing and eating candy with my dad.
' [Candy is among the many sweet tooth things in this book]


'I wonder... can you be in love with a girl and still like BTS?'


'I'm going to STOP acting like a KID and BECOME a TEENAGER.'


'[...] acting like a teenager feels awkward. Almost like a game. I guess I have to keep trying until it feels normal.'


'A weird thing: The more mature I seem to get, the more embarrassed I feel. But maybe that's how it's supposed to be?'


'Me now - Bruised. The last banana that nobody wants.'



From the author at the end: '[...] this book is for you who feel alone in all the madness of growing up.
I'm rooting for you.
'



Final Score: 4/5

Manga Review - 'Disney's Cruella: The Manga: Black, White, and Red' by Hachi Ishie

I really did not expect to like this as much as I did.

But... it's Cruella.

Manga Cruella is still Cruella, at least from the 2021 movie. Wild, spontaneous, creative, unconventional, eccentric, amazing, a mite unhinged, no-limits, no-boxes, no-effs-given Cruella. She can't hide her true self, even when she is trying to blend in and look "normal".

I love how she's drawn here - every panel featuring her (which is nearly all of them) is unique, stylish, edgy (figuratively and literally), and totally not conventionally attractive or pretty for a woman; if anything she's designed to look much older than her late teens to her twenties.

Estella/Cruella is a "crazy lady", and you cannot look away from her. She's like Miranda Priestly, Harley Quinn, the Beatles era and punk rock all rolled into one unstoppable storm. Villain or antiheroine, you adore her.

'Disney's Cruella: The Manga: Black, White, and Red' is not a direct adaptation of the 2021 film. It's a midquel to it, a minisode based on Estella's life when she is pickpocketing with Jasper and Horace in 1970s London. The manga is about her trying to figure herself out, how she's to be who she is meant to be. But she is not ready; she is not quite there yet. Not when she is still dealing with PTSD from a horrific tragedy in her childhood, and is living in poverty in a world that won't give women like her a chance to thrive and shine.

There are surprisingly a lot of life lessons to be taken away from this, especially for women who feel boxed and pressured by a patriarchal society that hates and fears them and wants to keep them in limited, safe, boring confines. In Estella's own words: "I may have gotten too used to hiding myself." 'Black, White, and Red' is about a young Cruella finding herself, and perhaps, unexpectedly on her part, helping other women find themselves, too; their own unique selves.

"The only person who can represent me is myself."

Tastes in clothes and fashion is a part of that expression.

It's quite beautiful. Very special. It's not really mad or maddening, but it's mad in that it loudly and powerfully breaks down the walls of conventional storytelling and character development. The story is not as weak and insubstantial as it might appear on a first read, and there is strong character analyses punching it up. If its messages don't hit you right way, they creep up on you, and you won't be able to forget any of it.

An example of unconventional story structuring, especially for a Disney product, is there is no villain in this little story. Unless you count the London cops, which I do. Eff the police. Eff the brutal upholders and abusers of a corrupt, unfair and unjust system.

I have to say that Jasper is drawn and written to be very insightful, and cute. In a way he's as eye-catching and irresistible as Estella.

Now, the negatives of 'Black, White, and Red' are:

First, its titular colours are never actually, well, coloured in properly in this black-and-white-only manga - of course red isn't shown - so in that sense nothing stands out visually. The cover is the most colour you're going to get out of it. Which is unfortunate since colour and expression are such majors themes here. The clothes presented could have been more if we could see the colours.

Second, the ending is a bit abrupt.

Third, it is obvious that the English translation process was done from the American English perspective, as the dialogue doesn't technically suit the 1970s British linguistics and dialect. So the historical setting and aesthetic aren't authentic, therefore not believable. Where's the slang? No slang in the lower-class-and-poverty-stricken streets of London, are you joking?! Throw some cockney in there, for pete's sake!!! We hardly ever call the police "cops", either. It's towards, not toward! And colour is spelled with a U over here!

And fourth, for what is a 'One Hundred and One Dalmatians' spinoff piece, and a Cruella de Vil character study, Jasper's and Horace's little dogs barely appear; in fact dogs in general are largely absent in 'Black, White, and Red'. No hint of Estella being "dangerous" with cute canines, unless you count her brief and slight annoyance with them at the very beginning, and the very end, of the manga. I like that at least the detail of Cruella "seeing spots" is downplayed and muted, not overdone like it easily could have been, for sometimes less is more, especially in psychological fields of study. Though another thing in the manga that is underused, but which doesn't need to be, is Horace. He hardly does or says anything. A sad waste, for he could have been a fine comic relief (not that Estella can't be funny, far from it) like he is in the movie.

I recommend 'Disney's Cruella: The Manga: Black, White, and Red' to fans of the 'Cruella' film, and to feminists and those studying feminism, believe it or not. Who knew there would be great insights to be found in a manga tie-in to a Disney Live Action Movie Remake and villain origin reimagining? I know, I'm shocked, too.

But then again, Cruella herself is supposed to be shocking and defy expectations, so it makes a bizarre kind of sense, intentionally done or not.

Outrageous and fabulous.


"Why hide when I'm this talented?"

"Their normal is abnormal for us."

"The only thing I trust is my own intuition."

"It is not for you to determine who I will become."

"When are you gonna wake up... Cruella?"


'Art will survive'


Final Score: 3.5/5

Wednesday, 28 February 2024

Book Review - 'The Crown' by Emily Kapff

'Treat the earth well: it was not given to you by your parents, it was loaned to you by your children. We do not inherit the earth from our ancestors, we borrow it from our children.’

- Native American proverb


'We have never met, you and I. I speak from the future which is not yours yet. It is being shaped now. [..] You have the power to pass down... a different kind of crown.'

- 'The Crown' by Emily Kapff



One of the most powerful and effective environmental message books I've ever read. It is about a young girl in the future - who could be any poor child, though I see her as a personification of Mother Nature, as well as a self-proclaimed princess (and queen) - who is on a hill of rubbish and waste, with her horse. This "princess" wears a crown made of rubbish, waste, chemicals and every other kind of mistake made by humanity, brought on by pollution and short-sightedness and late stage capitalism.

What is killing the earth is on this child's head - this is her generation.

Then, on the desolate landfill hill, she finds a book filled with fairy tales, and earth's wonders, such as its animals, wildlife, trees, and oceans. With that spark of hope, with that message about stories and how humans can and must do better, maybe her crown can look different in the future...

'The Crown' - a timely call to action, a wake-up klaxon for responsibility, a demand to do better to save our one and only planet we live on. It could not have come out at a more vital, pressing time. Climate change is real, and we need to do what we can to fix it, to heal the earth, for future generations.

Don't deride - this is our home we are talking about. Don't rob our children of the beautiful, wonderful, safe, healthy and free things in the world. Like breathable air.

I'm not a fan of the dreary, bleak, muddy, sometimes uncanny artwork, but it is suitable for the book, and it is in the service of getting its message across. I'm sure the inclusion of the horse is symbolic of life and the lost beauty of the earth or something, too.

Recommended to all ages.

Final Score: 3.5/5