WELCOME TO OCTOBER MAGICA!
Today I reread the first volume of the first 'Puella Magi Madoka Magica' spinoff manga I checked out, 'Puella Magi Madoka Magica: The Different Story, Vol 1'.
I confess to remembering pretty much nothing of 'The Different Story' spinoff before embarking on the October Magica quest. All I knew peripherally was that it is a, well, different story and retelling from the canon; it is from an alternate timeline, as opposed to the timeline we follow in the anime (time travel in stories opens up so much potential, doesn't it? As long as it's written thoughtfully and carefully). But I'm glad to be revisiting it, because it is really excellent, and it holds up well.
'Vol. 1' is, oddly, both a comfort read, and a deep dive depressing reel. The action sequences and witch designs are drawn fantastically, but what is most important is the character work. Meaning, Mami and Kyouko, and their blooming, yet tragic relationship. The manga does an amazing job showing their spirits soar and sour at crucial moments in their shared journey. It is wonderful and heartbreaking to read about.
This volume is Mami's and Kyouko's tragic tale. Theirs was a bond, made between two lonely magical girls who at first saw eye-to-eye on how to fight and defeat witches (for their grief seeds, as well as saving as many people as possible) and their no-less harmful familiars. They decided to team up and become friends, and learn from one another, so they were not alone in their secret, solitary and dangerous lives anymore. They could've been called shared soul sisters.
But after a horrific tragedy struck one magical girl's life - destroyed it entirely - she changed. Upended were her old viewpoints, and she was left a bereaved, broken and depressed magical girl who was no longer a selfless hero. She changed her methods, and how she saw things, and the world, and that included the nature of what wishes should be granted to transform into magical girls in the first place.
And so, the two once hopeful girls ended up fighting each other instead, and then, distraught and heartbroken, they parted ways.
It is the kind of tragedy that 'Puella Magi Madoka Magica' excels at.
Plus it's great to see Mami and Kyouko interact and be together, in a special soul unity of friendship, who are in each other's hearts always, when in the anime they are hardly shown in tandem, if they get to exist in the same place at the same time at all.
Evermore is it great, uplifting even, to witness a rapport between magical girls in 'Madoka Magica', every time, no matter how badly it'll turn out.
I wonder about what other unfamiliar and unlikely groups of magical girls are in the subsequent volumes...
Slight spoiler, but it is lovely that we, along with Mami, get a chance to see Kyouko's family, including her little sister Momo, while we can, while it lasts...
Wait, how do the magical girls already know about the upcoming Walpurgis Nacht (Night? The name seems to switch around in manga form)? I thought only Homura had that knowledge. Has the the gigantic witch of city-destructive power appeared somewhere else before, to have prematurely gained a reputation of sorts in the magical girl community? "Rumours" don't cut it. WTH?
I'm not a fan of the comedic inside covers of the manga volume this time round. The back cover especially seems homophobic and in bad taste (moreso if you're a Madoka and Homura shipper), even if it is meant to be a joke (it isn't funny) and teasing (again, nobody decent is laughing; it is just cruel and misguided "humour").
The focus of 'The Different Story, Vol 1' is entirely on Mami and Kyouko. Kyubey doesn't appear much, and Madoka, Sayaka and Homura don't show up until the last seven pages. Who will volumes 2 and 3 focus on? I seem to remember that 'The Different Story' as a whole is mainly about Mami? And Kyouko on the side, too, maybe? Everyone's an awesome character deserving of exploration and expansion, and in this particular instance I'd love to see more of Mami.
Mami Tomoe - beautiful, smart, hopeful, optimistic, mature, maternal, big-sisterly, a hand-holder, yet scared herself, and complex and tragic in every way; she suits the themes of 'Madoka Magica' perfectly.
Well, we'll see how it goes for any of the characters in 'The Different Story, Vol. 2'.
One ironical, foreshadowing line at the beginning, from a nameless magical girl to Mami:
"Don't overdo it. You only have one life, so protect it. [...] Don't go mistaking a familiar for a witch anymore, okay?"
It's more subtle than, say, "Don't go losing your head", at least.
Happy October Magica!
Final Score: 4.5/5
EDIT: My first review below really holds up. Blimey, did I write all that? I can't believe it.
Original Review:
A great manga addition to the 'Puella Magi Madoka Magica' franchise. Not having heard many positive things about its other spin-off titles, I stayed clear of them despite loving the original series so much. But that wasn't the case with 'The Different Story'. Plus it stars only the characters from the anime, so I was more than a little curious.
'Puella Magi Madoka Magica: The Different Story, Vol 1' doesn't just focus more on the backstories of the Magical Girls Mami Tomoe and Kyouko Sakura, nor does it only explore their never-seen-nor-established-before relationship with each other. When I read the last few pages I discovered that 'The Different Story' really is that: an alternative storyline from the one in the anime. The only tweak so far is the development of the tragic friendship (if you already know that 'Madoka Magica' is a tragic series, this shouldn't technically be considered a spoiler. If so, sorry) between Mami and Kyouko.
Mami is a Magical Girl who wants to save as many people from witches and familiars as possible. She doesn't want to be like the other Magical Girls who will wait for the familiars to kill people so that they will grow to become witches to destroy for power-ups for the Girls' soul gems. Yeah, the story is already pretty dark and cynical for a manga of this genre. Having performed her self-appointed duties for a year now, Mami meets the newbie Kyouko, who is more willing to try different techniques in fighting witches. Kyouko even asks Mami to take her on as her disciple, her student. Mami is to be her senpai.
The two instantly become best friends, having been lonely and lost for so long.
Mami even invents a phrase for Kyouko to yell out for one of her magical attacks. How adorable!
We see Kyouko's family in this manga, and the struggles she has to face in being both a Magical Girl and a priest's daughter. Her tragic past is explored in a lot more detail than in the anime series, making it more poignant towards the inevitable climax. I have never felt sorrier for Kyouko Sakura. It seems she really was an innocent, idealistic Magical Girl once.
And poor, poor little Momo...
Mami is perhaps the stronger of the two for sticking to her goals and ideals in the face of tragedy. She may even be interpreted as a big sisterly saint who only lets her guard down in the worst possible moments. But in a myriad of ways Kyouko's story is the most heartwrenching. You can't exactly blame the fourteen-year-old girl for turning and abandoning her senpai's view of life as a selfless Magical Girl. Heck, I'm impressed she didn't commit suicide after all she suffered through. You understand her reasoning, and why Mami's logic of protecting people and their happiness could be flawed.
Mami Tomoe once again is alone in the world, with no family and friends who share her understanding, and her desperate need to be a good hero and teacher to others.
The girls had a sisterly bond which started out so hopefully; to have it shatter is the final tragedy of this volume.
Kyuubey doesn't appear much here, which is just as well. Madoka and Sayaka don't show up until the very end, with Homura drawn ominously in one panel...
'The Different Story' has nice, expressive artwork (I especially love Mami’s numerous facial expressions), as well as being a good companion tale to the 'Madoka Magica' series. It is not nearly as violent or horrific as the original story - those sorts of scenes are either off-panel, implied or merely told to us - and it is a little short, with well-drawn but too-brief battle scenes. But the themes of friendships being tested, knowing what you are doing when trying to make other people happy, and what it truly means to be a so-called powerful person who thinks she knows all the right answers, are all present. The manga presents one or two different angles in viewing what it entails to be a Magical Girl.
No romance with a boy in sight, too. Was the author intending a kind of closer-than-friends vibe between Mami and Kyouko? Either way I welcome it; they are good together.
Enjoyable yet sad, I recommend ‘The Different Story’ to 'Madoka Magica' fans everywhere, who don't mind reading into a bit more tragedy and melancholy.
Final Score: 4.5/5
I'm not a fan of the comedic inside covers of the manga volume this time round. The back cover especially seems homophobic and in bad taste (moreso if you're a Madoka and Homura shipper), even if it is meant to be a joke (it isn't funny) and teasing (again, nobody decent is laughing; it is just cruel and misguided "humour").
The focus of 'The Different Story, Vol 1' is entirely on Mami and Kyouko. Kyubey doesn't appear much, and Madoka, Sayaka and Homura don't show up until the last seven pages. Who will volumes 2 and 3 focus on? I seem to remember that 'The Different Story' as a whole is mainly about Mami? And Kyouko on the side, too, maybe? Everyone's an awesome character deserving of exploration and expansion, and in this particular instance I'd love to see more of Mami.
Mami Tomoe - beautiful, smart, hopeful, optimistic, mature, maternal, big-sisterly, a hand-holder, yet scared herself, and complex and tragic in every way; she suits the themes of 'Madoka Magica' perfectly.
Well, we'll see how it goes for any of the characters in 'The Different Story, Vol. 2'.
One ironical, foreshadowing line at the beginning, from a nameless magical girl to Mami:
"Don't overdo it. You only have one life, so protect it. [...] Don't go mistaking a familiar for a witch anymore, okay?"
It's more subtle than, say, "Don't go losing your head", at least.
Happy October Magica!
Final Score: 4.5/5
EDIT: My first review below really holds up. Blimey, did I write all that? I can't believe it.
Original Review:
A great manga addition to the 'Puella Magi Madoka Magica' franchise. Not having heard many positive things about its other spin-off titles, I stayed clear of them despite loving the original series so much. But that wasn't the case with 'The Different Story'. Plus it stars only the characters from the anime, so I was more than a little curious.
'Puella Magi Madoka Magica: The Different Story, Vol 1' doesn't just focus more on the backstories of the Magical Girls Mami Tomoe and Kyouko Sakura, nor does it only explore their never-seen-nor-established-before relationship with each other. When I read the last few pages I discovered that 'The Different Story' really is that: an alternative storyline from the one in the anime. The only tweak so far is the development of the tragic friendship (if you already know that 'Madoka Magica' is a tragic series, this shouldn't technically be considered a spoiler. If so, sorry) between Mami and Kyouko.
Mami is a Magical Girl who wants to save as many people from witches and familiars as possible. She doesn't want to be like the other Magical Girls who will wait for the familiars to kill people so that they will grow to become witches to destroy for power-ups for the Girls' soul gems. Yeah, the story is already pretty dark and cynical for a manga of this genre. Having performed her self-appointed duties for a year now, Mami meets the newbie Kyouko, who is more willing to try different techniques in fighting witches. Kyouko even asks Mami to take her on as her disciple, her student. Mami is to be her senpai.
The two instantly become best friends, having been lonely and lost for so long.
Mami even invents a phrase for Kyouko to yell out for one of her magical attacks. How adorable!
We see Kyouko's family in this manga, and the struggles she has to face in being both a Magical Girl and a priest's daughter. Her tragic past is explored in a lot more detail than in the anime series, making it more poignant towards the inevitable climax. I have never felt sorrier for Kyouko Sakura. It seems she really was an innocent, idealistic Magical Girl once.
And poor, poor little Momo...
Mami is perhaps the stronger of the two for sticking to her goals and ideals in the face of tragedy. She may even be interpreted as a big sisterly saint who only lets her guard down in the worst possible moments. But in a myriad of ways Kyouko's story is the most heartwrenching. You can't exactly blame the fourteen-year-old girl for turning and abandoning her senpai's view of life as a selfless Magical Girl. Heck, I'm impressed she didn't commit suicide after all she suffered through. You understand her reasoning, and why Mami's logic of protecting people and their happiness could be flawed.
Mami Tomoe once again is alone in the world, with no family and friends who share her understanding, and her desperate need to be a good hero and teacher to others.
The girls had a sisterly bond which started out so hopefully; to have it shatter is the final tragedy of this volume.
Kyuubey doesn't appear much here, which is just as well. Madoka and Sayaka don't show up until the very end, with Homura drawn ominously in one panel...
'The Different Story' has nice, expressive artwork (I especially love Mami’s numerous facial expressions), as well as being a good companion tale to the 'Madoka Magica' series. It is not nearly as violent or horrific as the original story - those sorts of scenes are either off-panel, implied or merely told to us - and it is a little short, with well-drawn but too-brief battle scenes. But the themes of friendships being tested, knowing what you are doing when trying to make other people happy, and what it truly means to be a so-called powerful person who thinks she knows all the right answers, are all present. The manga presents one or two different angles in viewing what it entails to be a Magical Girl.
No romance with a boy in sight, too. Was the author intending a kind of closer-than-friends vibe between Mami and Kyouko? Either way I welcome it; they are good together.
Enjoyable yet sad, I recommend ‘The Different Story’ to 'Madoka Magica' fans everywhere, who don't mind reading into a bit more tragedy and melancholy.
Final Score: 4.5/5