Reviewed in bullet points:
• I really like 'Bad Dream: A Dreamer Story', and I truly believe it is important that it and comics and stories like it exist. Never take any representation of a minority group for granted, especially right now, in the real world, where people are being politically, societally and deliberately targeted, scapegoated, silenced, and erased and made more and more vulnerable. These stories should be told ubiquitously. That being said, 'Bad Dream' still has its issues, and unfortunate implications, for all its good intentions.
• It contains the same problems I had with 'Galaxy: The Prettiest Star', which is its predecessor: notably, the meanspirited and depressing marginalised-victim-blaming, and pro-fearmongering and paranoia. I know this is unintentional, but it's present nonetheless. Further thought and care in stories about frequently dehumanised, scapegoated and erased groups of people need to be implemented; further hurt and harm need not be done (and this can happen even in #ownvoices stories).
• Also like in 'Galaxy', the bullies and abusers of the minority main character are never really called out on, if at all. It is very important that they are shown to be held accountable for their words and actions - and properly shown to be in the wrong. When they say and do terrible and abhorrent things, the reaction and consequences of such should be morally appropriate, not ignored, glossed over and brushed aside, like its "normal", when it isn't, and shouldn't be. This point is especially vital in a story aimed at younger audiences.
• But 'Bad Dream' does surpass and transcend 'Galaxy' in that its protagonist actually is transgender, as well as a space alien; no disingenuous, airy-fairy metaphor here (though from what I remember from reading 'Hawkgirl: Once Upon a Galaxy', it is retconned that Galaxy/Taylor really is transgender, in that she was assigned male at birth and it wasn't just a disguise on earth...I need to reread 'Hawkgirl: Once Upon a Galaxy'). 'Bad Dream' is the real deal in trans representation in superheroes in a DC comic. It makes for much stronger and more solid and effective characterisation, coming from a real and relatable place, and the undeniable and inescapable visibility and voice! Metaphors, allegories and subtexts are only used by cowardly and capitalist writers.
• I like Nia Nal, the trans half-alien teen protagonist. I liked following her on her journey - her story - of self-acceptance. She is just like an insecure, isolated, lonely, scared teenage girl. That she is treated like a burden for existing by her own birth community and family is heartbreaking. (I'm always down for brown-haired heroines, too.) However, she is rather too full of self-hatred and self-pity, and apologises far too much to people when she is the victim 100% of the time and she did nothing wrong. I wish that aspect of her character got explored, along with her serious self-esteem issues.
• I absolutely hate Maeve, Nia's sister. She fills in the role of Taylor's shitty male "friend" from 'Galaxy'. She is the textbook definition of a fake ally and fair-weather family member; she is never there for Nia when it matters, and is no better than Nia's bigoted bullies. She secretly despises her trans sister with a passion; she makes it clear she sees Nia as a burden and inconvenience, wishing she would disappear, all while pretending (very poorly) to care for her. I understand that Maeve has insecurities of her own, and is under a lot of pressure, with an alien legacy to uphold that she's pinned her whole identity and sense of self on. She fears failure and inadequacy more than anything. But it doesn't excuse her taking her problems out on Nia, who, again, never did anything wrong. Maeve is a selfish, self-absorbed cow, and honestly I'm glad she isn't in the comic much.
• Nia's alien species, from her mother Isabel's side, are called the Naltorians. The females experience prophetic dreams, and possess precognition and foresight...yet this power, belonging to Nia, Isabel and other female characters, isn't utilised or effective when it would be most useful, because there wouldn't be a plot or any danger in the comic otherwise. Visions and dreams are conveniently limited.
• The backstory of Isabel is a bit inconsistent and muddled, and why isn't Nia hyped at all that her mother was apparently an alien superhero, the leader of the Seers? Her teammates and adventures are literally presented in comic books. Who made them? Did Isabel create those comics herself, solely to inspire her daughters? Were they only widely distributed on her planet of origin, Naltor? What about on earth? It isn't clear. Nia fangirls over the comics, and why wouldn't she, when they are "true stories" about her alien superhero mum? She has a poster of the Seers - of her superhero mum - on her bedroom wall! Where did that come from? Why is this never brought up?
• Isabel, unlike certain other characters, is held accountable for her shortcomings concerning Nia, and she receives proper redemption. She apologises to Nia, profusely, and assures her daughter that nothing that's happened is her fault. Isabel is a good mother, who acknowledges her mistakes and is willing to improve herself for her children's sake. It's too bad in the end...no, sorry, spoilers. Moving on.
• Nia's human father, Paul, is practically a nonentity who's barely around, but in the little he does appear he is shown to be like Isabel: supportive, if flawed, and always trying.
• I like the found family aspect of 'Bad Dream', and Nia's new queer friend group that she stumbles upon when she runs away to Metropolis. This group has Galaxy, aka Taylor, from 'Galaxy: The Prettiest Star', and her girlfriend from that comic, Kat, and Yvette, a trans Black girl (oh, and Argus, Galaxy's talking dog). They, and their unapologetic queer home and community, are the best part of the comic. So colourful, and so much joy! A respite and breath of fresh air from Nia's miserable life!
• Queer sanctuaries, parties, and fashion shows are the best - those scenes brim with positivity, love, community, and shining and sparkling colours in 'Bad Dream'. Sparkling starshine on! A-Town (aka Gay-Town) is a comfy and friendly safe space.
• I deeply appreciate the depiction of angry, bigoted, ham-fisted, hatemongering talk show and radio personalities, and politicians and propagandists (there is no difference, really), who are inexplicably given a platform and position of power and influence. It's not just LBGTQ+ prejudice and themes in 'Bad Dream' - racism and xenophobia are touched on as well. All bigotry is connected, after all, and a result of white male supremacy and the hierarchical, capitalist patriarchy. Diversity, diverse people, they exist - deal with it, fascists.
• Speaking of, I love that, during a talk between Nia, Taylor, Kat and Yvette, it is suggested that one of the reasons why transphobia, homophobia, and general queerphobia and queer hatred exist is because of jealousy. Bigots, fascists and conservatives (again, no difference between them) are cowards who resent people who are bravely, expressly themselves, and who dare to be happy and love themselves, in a world ruled by conformity and fear. By "purity" and "order" and a rigid, limited and boring idea of what is "normal". By, yes, if the self-loathing fascists and right wing politically minded had their way, eugenics, anti-humanity, and capitalism.
• Yvette's backstory about being sent to a conversion therapy camp by her parents is another tragically realistic detail that needed to be spoken. Parents who do that to their own children are abusers - it is never done out of "love", that is a lie. Conversion therapy is a deadly scam, and the states that legalise it are hands down legalising abuse, child abuse. Abuse is not love. PSA: No sexual orientation is a disease, no gender identity is a disease - there is nothing to "cure", nothing that can be changed.
• Nia has anxiety, and panic attacks. The rep there is not that great, and is demonstrated like an afterschool special add-on, but it's a believable touch for her character. It's suitable, realistic and necessary, given the dark, symbolic prophetic dreams, and other surprise powers, of the young, confused and overwhelmed Nia.
• Galaxy/Taylor is a purple, trans alien princess and superhero with a talking dog. Like Nia/Dreamer, she deserves to be an icon, and she deserves to be happy. Her girlfriend Kat is Black and has a prosthetic leg. You can't fault 'Bad Dream' for its awesome diversity and representation.
• Finally, for the record: I was unfamiliar with Nicole Maines and her character Nia Nal, aka Dreamer, from the 'Supergirl' TV series, before reading 'Bad Dream', as I have only watched the first season. I probably should have led the review with that info. But absolutely good on Nicole Maines for all that she does, and for her work on 'Bad Dream: A Dreamer Story', which is #ownvoices, and I wish her all the best. Dreamer - the first transgender superhero on TV FTW!
Overall, an enjoyable yet bittersweet YA coming-of-age trans superheroine comic, containing truths that must be told.
Oh, and one last message, delivered to aid future LBGTQ+ stories, in light (not dark!) of the flaws of both 'Bad Dream: A Dreamer Story' and 'Galaxy: The Prettiest Star': Just let the queers be happy already!
And as I pointed out in my 'Galaxy: The Prettiest Star' review, paraphrased: Stories should not only reflect reality, but show how reality can be better.
Final Score (for 'Bad Dream'): 3.5/5