Wednesday, 5 July 2023

Graphic Novel Review - 'Basil and Oregano' by Melissa Capriglione

Spoilers ahead.


Artemis Crescent's graphic novel review of something she should have loved - that features practically everything she loves. But unfortunately, ultimately doesn't. Because bad writing - messy, poorly planned, problematic writing on a massive, moon-sized scale - shouldn't be brushed aside in favour of aesthetics and good ideas. For execution is everything.

Yep, right after my review of 'Fae and the Moon' (which can be read here) comes a review of a similar graphic novel from 2023 - ridiculously, unbearably cute magical girl power set in a fantastical world, that I desperately wanted to adore and keep. But my sound, logical brain won out over my heart. I know I've been repeating myself lately, but I will reiterate: 'Fae and the Moon' and 'Basil and Oregano' are middling, messy, random, confusing and baffling stories, and excellent artwork and ideas don't change that.

'Basil and Oregano' is a step-up in that it is an LBGTQ+ story - lovingly so, in fact. No one is straight, and practically half the cast are not cisgender. Queer, trans and nonbinary people are the norm in this world that is a reflection of our contemporary age but with witches and magic. It is like 'Harry Potter' meets 'The Great British Bake Off', and it is set in a wonderful dream world where queerphobia doesn't exist. The graphic novel should have been revolutionary; it should have been praised to the heavens, and beloved by everyone on Planet Earth. But... well.

Here is a list of things wrong with 'Basil and Oregano':


• At the very beginning, the teen witch protagonist Basil Eyres is given an apron that belonged to one of her dads, before her senior year at magiculinary boarding school begins. The apron is special and important to them. You'd think it would come up again. But it doesn't. Basil only wears it in one exam scene, and that's it. In fact, the magical cooking students are hardly ever seen wearing aprons, just their uniforms. So what's the point of the aprons if they're not going to be worn for anything important - or for anything at all, really?

• On the subject of pointless things being brought up - this time out of the effing blue - and nothing is done with them and then they are straight-up forgotten about, there's Basil's plant, named Poe. It suddenly appears in her dorm room eighty two pages into the book, but Basil treats it like it's her favourite and most constant companion and pet. It appears in two scenes, and then it is gone, never to be mentioned again. In the middle of the book, Basil experiences a magic burnout, which manifests in the form of greenery forming around her and on her as she falls into a coma. I had thought that the plant in her room had something to do with this at first, but no. There is no indication that Poe is anything but an ordinary potted plant, which gets knocked over amidst Basil's burnout, and then we never see it again. WHAT. IS. THE. POINT. OF. THE. PLANT? WHY INCLUDE THE PLANT? DID THIS COMIC NOT GO THROUGH ANY EDITING STAGES? ANY PLANNING STAGES?

• As other reviewers have pointed out, how scholarships and tuition work in the Porta Bella Magiculinary Academy is effed up to all hell. To achieve in this school-- no, to even attend this school, you either have to be richer than gods, or be the top student at everything, in most of your classes, in most of your exams (which are numerous and constant), or else you lose your scholarship and will be kicked out of the system. It is not really a school: it is a competition, a winner-takes-all capitalist nightmare, culminating in an actual public baking contest that is the school year's final exam/round. Apparently, one person a year wins above all others and gets to win at life, while the other students who have worked just as painfully and dangerously hard (unless they're, again, richer than Midas) lose their chances for good, and can go eff themselves. It is not until the very end that this is called out on for the unfair system it is that only benefits shareholders, and it is changed (by rich people in positions of power, because of course), because it needs to, for how the hell will this society function otherwise? With its thousands of broke, disadvantaged, burned-out and jobless people, their dreams and passions destroyed and talents and hard work gone to waste? Every one of the teachers at the academy, as well as the Arch Chef and the rest of the administration, should be ashamed of themselves for putting so much pressure on teenagers. They expect them to be perfect at everything, all the time, and even that won't be enough for this single-winner-takes-all batter-royale school of misery and exploitation. These poor students are killing themselves with the stress, if not literally than through burnout and injuring themselves. And stress does kill, especially the young. In 'Basil and Oregano', in an LBGTQ+-friendly world, capitalism still runs rampant and uncontrolled. Like in the real world, too, it is also ableist AF.

• How exactly does the magic in this world work? Does it only apply to magiculinary, the art of cooking and baking? But it is also used for cleaning clothes in a flash (dishwashing spells, they're called), and for hypnotizing dragons seemingly at random and making them attack a specific mark. Magiculinary is a huge deal, but it is unclear if it the only deal for every magic user in the world. If the reason why this specific type of magic is focused on so heavily and universally is because it is the singular, be-all-and-end-all of magic... for some reason. It is all anyone talks about, at any rate.

• How is magical cooking any different from cooking without magic? Is it only that ordinary cooking without magical utensils (which resemble wands from various cute Magical Girl anime) is slower? Is it that the taste of the food will be better with magic? Or when the food is prepared using magic? Perhaps I am overthinking it, but I am confused.

• In the climax, in the final magical chef exam/festival/public competition for the teen girls' lives that is out in the open, a dragon is summoned out of a mountain by resident mean girl Xynthia, to wreck and sabotage Basil's and Arabella Oregano (her love interest)'s cooking. It is literally the first ever mention, let alone sight, of dragons existing in this world. Familiars, cute magical creatures, and familiars that turn "dark", sure, but no dragons. No huge and potentially dangerous beasts like that.

• To add insult to something that was already pulled out of the writer's backside at the last minute, after the rampaging dragon is tamed by Basil and Arabella using bonding over food, Arch Chef Spink recognises it as an ancient familiar from over a hundred years ago (they'd dated the dragon's owner's grandson in college), and they call it "Arrabbiata", like that means something, other than the name of a pasta sauce. The other characters act like they know the name and the legend, but it is the first time the reader hears of them! No hints, no foreshadowing, nothing. What should have been plot developments are, well, not. They are not developed in the slightest, and come right out of nowhere. It is unbelievably sloppy, and so poorly executed I have to wonder how the book got published as it is.

• Basil starts her and Arabella's bond-over-food plan on the dragon by... insulting it and then whacking it in the face with her utensil. It is when she injures and brings it down that she executes the pacifying-it-gently-and-patiently-with-food spell breaking strategy. Counterintuitive, contradictory and self-defeating don't begin to describe it. It looks like abuse to me. Making it worse is the dragon is under a spell and not acting of its own free will. As aggressive as Basil is portrayed as being sometimes, including towards people she supposedly loves, often inconsistently, though it's mainly due to stress and pressure, this is by far the worst thing she does in the comic - and it is framed as the right thing to do!

• Why is Xynthia being deliberately and obviously evil in her sabotaging plans for Basil and Arabella? She sends her familiar to stalk and spy on them, and to steal their stuff, and then she actually posts about it on her Prestogram (heh) account, bragging about how evil she is and that she's 'Totally not up to anything shady at all.' (Yes. She writes this. It is a direct quote. I am not making it up). And Basil and Arabella do absolutely nothing about it. They let her get away with it, and don't try to stop her plan. WHY?! GO TELL A TEACHER IF YOU CAN'T STOP HER YOURSELF - THERE IS EVIDENCE! XYNTHIA HAS WILLFULLY INCRIMINATED HERSELF! THE DRAGON INCIDENT WOULD NEVER HAVE HAPPENED IF OUR "HEROES" HAD DONE LITERALLY ANYTHING TO PREVENT IT BEFOREHAND!

• Why is Xynthia easily forgiven at the end? Why is Arabella's controlling mother, who is ashamed of her nonmagical daughter, easily forgiven, and redeemed at the drop of a hat? And so are Arch Chef Spink, the administration and the teachers? People don't change that quickly, and don't deserve to be forgiven that quickly after a lifetime of abuse.

• Xynthia's arm is in a cast after the dragon attack she caused. It is the only thing of consequence for her actions. She receives no punishment whatsoever, for the mass destruction and nearly getting people killed. With her light, little cast, she quite literally gets a slap on the wrist after everything she's done. One "sorry" and heavy family troubles - plus desperation and stress due to the school's impractical and inhumane competitive tuition policy - don't erase a terrorist attack brought on by mean girl pettiness!

• Why is the title of the graphic novel 'Basil and Oregano', and not 'Basil and Arabella'? Oregano is Arabella's surname, but she is never referred to as just Oregano, and certainly not by her partner in love, Basil Eyres. Is it because of the fame and prestigiousness of Arabella's family name? That's classist, and goes against the story's message of individualism and loving yourself for who you are, doesn't it? For consistency and fairness, the book should be called 'Eyres and Oregano'.

• Do two witches have to always share the familiar they've summoned for help for school festivals? Or is that only as a starting point, for sharing and learning, and a witch can bond with their own familiar later? But where would they get one? Will they have to inherit one from their family? But which is it - summon a familiar by magic, or inheritance? Does it depend on different circumstances? What if there are no inheritance familiars left, having died of old age? Is it okay for a witch to have no familiar? To have no "help" in their magiculinary? Another poorly thought out worldbuilding point, leaving behind so many questions.

• Basil's two best friends, Villy, who is nonbinary, and Addy, who is Black and trans, should have received more page time and development. And a resolution to their story arcs and partnership.

• During the dragon attack, Arch Chef Spink calls out to the teachers, "Let's get the townspeople and the kings out of here!" Wait, WHAT? WHAT!? WHAT KINGS!? There's been no mention, no indication, of any type of monarchy, nor royalty, existing in this society until that line. And who are the kings? Are they any of the male rich people in the background in a few panels? What makes them any different from the other rich, snobbish people we see? Why was the line included at all when it is dropped from nowhere, for no reason, and makes zero sense? ARGH! SO MANY ARSE PULLS IN THIS SINGLE SCENE! AND IT'S THE CLIMAX!


Easily fixable flaws, that weren't fixed. I am flummoxed, and disappointed. What a waste of potential.

However, like with 'Fae and the Moon', and other cute fantasy girl power graphic novels like it, there are good points. The diversity is fantastic. The artwork and colours are wonderfully done, and freaking adorable. It is like Paulina Ganucheau's body of work. The whole aesthetic of 'Basil and Oregano' screams cute and magical. Basil and Arabella's familiar, the puppy/tomato hybrid named, well, Tomato, is a cute mascot character, who isn't sidelined, forgotten about, or rendered useless to the story. Basil and Arabella's relationship is pretty much the most well developed thing in the comic. It is sweet, lovely, angsty, complex, and they work nicely together. They have chemistry, they have substance, and they spend a lot of time together; enough needed for their romantic relationship to develop naturally.

I wanted to love 'Basil and Oregano' and 'Fae and the Moon'. Badly. Incredibly. But I can't.

I'm truly sorry, really, to the writers and artists hard at work and lucky enough to have their work published. I don't mean to crush your dreams. I do appreciate and understand your efforts, and your art and passion. But I am a critic, and a critic's got to critique, and point out flaws. I believe the people who have worked on these graphic novels will, by jove, by hope, improve and get better overtime. They certainly show promise and aptitude.

I am Fantasy Feminist critic Artemis Crescent, signing out.

Final Score: 2.5/5

Graphic Novel Review - 'Fae and the Moon' by Franco Aureliani (Writer), Catherine Satrun (Artist), Sarah Satrun (Artist)

Spoilers ahead.


Artemis Crescent's graphic novel review of something she should have loved - that features practically everything she loves. But unfortunately, ultimately doesn't. Because bad writing - messy, poorly planned, problematic writing on a massive, moon-sized scale - shouldn't be brushed aside in favour of aesthetics and good ideas. For execution is everything.

My feelings on 'Fae and the Moon' are similar to other graphic novels I've read recently that seemed up my alley, such as 'Cheshire Crossing' and 'Garlic and the Vampire', but had left me disappointed in the end. Mainly due to the aforementioned messiness, confusion, and lacklustre execution (though 'Garlic and the Vampire' is admittedly objectively far superior to the rest, I still expected more out of it).

My 'Fae and the Moon' review won't be the first of its kind I write today. Next one is coming up.

Here is a list of things wrong with 'Fae and the Moon':


• The setting is very limited - to Fae's house, and underneath her house, basically. We only see two panels featuring other people, who are Fae's neighbours, who she never interacts with, and we never see them again.

• There is really no point to Fae's mother's scrapbook and handmade book of potions and spells, other than setting up a blue flower as being a plot point for later on.

• Speaking of Fae's mother, who is she exactly? What is she? Is she a goddess? A witch? Is she immortal? In this world, she actually created the moon, presumably to keep any "dark creatures", who had existed since the beginning of time, at bay. It's not clear how long ago the creation of the moon happened. Was this from even before Fae was born? I have no freaking clue.

• Who are the mice, Frik and Frak, in relation to Fae's mother? In the end she acts like she knows them, and implied she'd sent them to look after Fae while she was gone. Huh?! And did Fae name them? They're nontalking animals, so she must have. But if not, then... what?!

• Why did Frik and Frak steal random stuff from Fae's house and keep them underground? This isn't brought up again.

• How come some animals can talk, while others, like the mice, can't?

• Speaking of, there is no real point to the talking Rat King and his rat horde, either. They could have been cut out of the comic and no difference would have been made. They could have been replaced by any other antagonist role, and no difference would have been made. Their "vermin in hiding taking back and taking over the surface world" plot goes absolutely nowhere. They're expendable, and once the Rat King, who wants the moon's power for himself, is suddenly, swiftly killed off by the dragon (oh, I'll get to him), the rats bugger off, never to be seen or mentioned again. Since they're presented as being an ostracised, marginalised minority race, not wanting to be shamed, killed and forced into hiding anymore, this is more than iffy.

• How did the Rat King know that it was Fae who took the moon from the sky? Never explained!

• The dragon, who we first see destroying Fae's house in trying to find the moon (which Fae had taken down in the hopes that it might bring her missing mother back to her) and Fae's mother (I think?). He is portrayed majorly as a violent brute - remember, he kills the Rat King, squishes him, but the comic doesn't remember, after the fact. Suddenly, at the end, when he is beaten down and dying, he becomes sympathetic - information is dropped on the reader about how Fae's mother had looked after him when he was a hatchling, when "others only wanted to destroy me" (huh? What? Who? Where? Why?!). She apparently just left him as soon as he could look after himself. She didn't bother to see him again afterwards. Sounds like she straight up abandoned him, but the dragon still sees her as his mother. Some mother. This supposedly took place before Fae was born. The dragon loves the mother and wants to protect her - then why did he not try to find her even before the moon went missing?! - and by extension he now wants to protect Fae. Citation needed. He destroyed part of her house with her inside it in his introduction! Even if he didn't know who she was at that point, it's still sloppy writing. Plus, he later says he was trying to stop the monster who was responsible for Fae's mother's disappearance. *Deep breath*, why did he not say so before!? To the scared little girl who looks like her mother in her house!? It could have saved a whole bunch of misunderstandings, such as Fae thinking that it was the dragon who was responsible for her mother's disappearance, because of an extremely vague dream she had (seriously, don't ask, it never makes any sense). He only cared about the moon in his first appearance. His motivation changes more than the moon phases. The dragon, whose name is Kulkan, in the climactic battle, refers to Fae as his "little sister"... and Fae immediately starts referring to him as her brother, despite them barely knowing each other and meeting only under violent, life-and-death circumstances. Also out of nowhere, Kulkan officially becomes part of the family, and Fae's mother's other child... who she'd abandoned for years. What BS.

• How did Kulkan find Fae's mother's house so quickly, years after she left him, if she was moving around constantly whilst in hiding?

• And what was that line from Kulkan calling himself "selfish once", like the Rat King... right as he kills the rodent? It doesn't come up again. Does it link to his past about others trying to kill him as a baby? Allow me to repeat the mantra of this graphic novel: What? Why? Who? When? Where? How? Huh?!

• Fae didn't 100% believe in her mother's stories about the moon and blue flowers and whatnot - they were more like fairy tales to her than anything. She didn't believe that dragons existed until one destroys part of her house. But talking rabbits, talking rats, smart mice, not to mention her being able to take the moon itself right out of the sky using ladders and it then somehow being small enough for her to hide in her cloak, her house, and in the chest in her room, all of this is normal to her. Not worth even commenting on.

• Now onto the talking rabbit himself, Percival. Initially he is set up to be Fae's friend, mentor, and guardian in place of her missing mother. He is like the cute animal mascot common in all magical girl-like media. But then - twist - just over halfway through the comic, he is revealed to be the true villain of the story the whole time. It's a decent and clever twist, though sadly I knew it was coming because someone on Goodreads carelessly revealed it in the first paragraph of their non-spoiler review. Regardless, it doesn't stop the What? Why? Who? When? Where? How? Huh?! mantra of everything. Why is Percival, or whoever he is and whatever he is called, so evil? Why does he want to take over the world? It can't just be because he is a creature of darkness, repelled by the moon. That's racist, isn't it? Why did it take so long for this shapeshifting monster of pure evil, who has existed since time began (however long ago that was in the context of this vague fantasy world and its poor worldbuilding), to find Fae's mother and attempt to deceive her into pulling the moon from the sky? Space is warped and time is bendable in this world and story. Why did he want to find the moon at all once it was gone from the sky, thanks to his tricking Fae into retrieving it herself and hiding it (he didn't count on her doing that specifically, but plot contrivance is plot contrivance)? The moon's gone, he's free in his power at night, and he can rule over everything. He doesn't really need the moon's power. But then he is immune to the moon's power in the sky? Or is less affected than other dark creatures, due to his shapeshifting? Why would the moon being different colours affect its power? In what ways? This point about the colours of the moon also ends up meaning nothing in the grand scheme of things. HOW WAS THIS COMIC PUBLISHED?! Why would Percival bother with the deception of both Fae and her mother at all? He's powerful (not to mention immortal) enough without them and their (witch? goddess?) powers. Whether or not the moon exists is in fact inconsequential to him. IT MAKES NO SENSE!

• It is made clearer at the end that apparently Percival had "killed" Fae's mother by completely absorbing her into him, and it wasn't enough power, so he then came after Fae for her power. Er, why was absorbing the mother, physically and in essence, not enough for him to take the moon? Why does he want the moon again, especially when he has its creator's power inside of him? How did he absorb her anyway? Again, why bother deceiving either of them when he could just absorb them and their power from the get-go?! Percival, in his true monster form, is defeated - killed, I think, though it's not made clear - far too easily by Fae beating him about with the moon he should be immune to. And his flowing blood, together with Fae's tears, make more blue flowers bloom, and free her mother. Thus they are reunited. It really would have been better for the storyline about grief if the mother never came back, if Fae had learned to move on, and grow from there. It feels like a copout.

• Just before Fae beats monster Percival over the head with the moon, she pulls up a weed from the ground (a blue flower stem? I have no frikin' and frakin' clue) and squeezes it, causing her hand to bleed (from its thorns? Its stinging nettles? Once again, I don't know). Why does she do this? It ends up doing absolutely nothing. It affects absolutely nothing. It doesn't even turn the moon in her hands red, indicating a difference in power, like how blue flowers combined with Fae's and her mother's magic can turn it blue. In fact, the weed and the blood disappear from Fae's hand when she first hits Percival with the moon. WHAT WAS THE POINT OF THAT?! HOW DID THIS GET PUBLISHED?

• At the very end, when Fae's mother comes back, Fae mentions that her mother dropped her key in her Moon garden the night she disappeared, and that is why Fae had it around her neck throughout the story. This is literally the first mention of the "found Mother's key in Moon garden" plot point. Fae just has it, and the reader has no idea how she got it up until that moment. The mother is seen wearing it in a couple of panels in flashbacks, but otherwise there is no indication that she ever wore it, as "special" and "important" as it is. This seems like both a writer and an artist problem and miscommunication. I say once more, HOW DID THIS GET PUBLISHED?

• The mother (okay, her name is I'Lette, but I can't be arsed to constantly type that) also drops the bomb at the end: "The power does not run through the veins of every generation, but it seems to be within you [Fae]", and she has family outside of her little house of choice, to hide away from the dark creatures and to protect Fae. Um, WHAT? I thought she was immortal. What generations? What family? I thought she and Fae were the only ones in the world with moon powers, hence why Percival targeted them. How old is she? HOW LONG AGO DID SHE CREATE THE BLOODY MOON?! And why did she feel it necessary to go into hiding from creatures of darkness when she is powerful enough on her own, AND with her moon?


Phew! There are other blatant flaws, but I'm too tired out to write more. It's all so baffling and confusing.

But despite everything above, I don't hate 'Fae and the Moon'. It does contain good points. It is very cute, cartoony and sweet, with great artwork, and I can easily see it being pitched as a pilot on Cartoon Network, Nickelodeon, or the Disney Channel. It has decent action scenes. I adore the colours, and the elements and motifs of the moon, magic, animals, gardens, cute tea sets, and mother and daughter bonds.

I only wish the story made sense.

Stay tuned for another review of a middling, messy, baffling fantasy girl power graphic novel I seriously wanted to love.

[EDIT: The review is now up! You can read it here.]

Final Score: 2.5/5

Graphic Novel Review - 'M Is for Monster' by Talia Dutton

2023 EDIT: Part of my 2023 clear-up, of books I no longer like, or am no longer interested in, or remember well as standing out, or find as special anymore, or I otherwise will not miss.

Final Score: 3.5/5





Original Review:



A touching and teary diverse horror graphic novel.

It's a more feminine and feminist retelling of (no less feminist pioneer) Mary Shelley's 'Frankenstein', about a scientist, Frances Ai, who tries to bring her younger sister, Maura, back from the dead - always trying to achieve the impossible, with, um, successful mistakes along the way, and trying to deal with her grief and guilt. But the monster--no, the person, she "revives" isn't her sister. She has just created new life; suddenly and unexpectedly, someone new has been brought into existence, who will be looking to find herself and forge her own identity. But Frances doesn't care about any of that; she only wants her sister back, by any means. The person she brought to life in her sister's stitched up body, called "M", is terrified of being taken apart and dead again, so she attempts to pretend to be Maura, for Frances's sake as well as her own. She'll have help from the strangest place along the way...

However, living up to other people's expectations, and trying to be a literal replacement for someone else, is not living. Certainly not for M, created and born yesterday. What can she do when being an individual - being herself - could mean her actual death?

M is an experiment gone "wrong", and she is all alone in the world. Or is she? She is not a mistake, nor a monster, but will the grief-stricken Frances ever see that (when other characters have already)? Will she ever move on, and appreciate what's in front of her, in life?

Entertaining, tragic, and oddly charming, with appropriate teal and black and white and cute-leaning towards-creepy artwork, that is 'M Is for Monster' by debut graphic novel author Talia Dutton. The themes of grief, moving on, appreciating what is there and what you have, family, and identity are portrayed exceedingly well.

The characters are great. I love the representation of female scientists, even "mad" ones. Plus friendly old neighbour ladies. Frances is also married to her nonbinary assistant, Gin, who is funny and a right ol' charmer, and often the voice of reason, and in keeping Frances grounded and rational. The married couple are caring, comforting and supportive, and their chemistry is loving and lovely.

There are only, like, five characters in the whole comic, but it's enough for a minimal concept like this. It's set entirely on a hill/valley (with a giant tree to contemplate under, too), in an ambiguous time period. Very reminiscent of 'Frankenstein', only with a more positive and soft atmosphere and society.

Oh, and magic also exists (it's once called an "arcane source"), and is nonchalantly used in everything to do with science, including physics - even freaking aerodynamics - which is weird, and feels unnecessary, but whatever.

I feel like I've already summed up my thoughts and feelings on 'M Is for Monster', spoiler-free.

So here are my spoiler-y thoughts below:


Apparently ghosts exist in this world, on top of everything else, and Maura shows up as a mirror ghost who only M can see, hear, and talk to. Nice twist on the seeing-yourself-in-the-mirror-and-who-you-are-on-the-outside-isn't-who-you-are-on-the-inside theme there. It is with the snarky ghost's help that the newly born M manages to convince Frances that she is Maura - very poorly, mind you, but Frances is desperate enough that she wants to believe that her sister is back, despite everything. As strange as this whole plot development is, I have a theory on how it could work. The comic is subtle about it... or maybe it is unintentional, and isn't there, and I'm pulling it out of thin air. But regardless, here it is: A few times Frances talks about one of her science experiments involving telepathy and communicating through other planes of existence. Could the experiment have worked, in a way she didn't intend, like all her other experiments, and that's how Maura's "ghost" can communicate, through mirrors, from the "other side", or plane, that is death? A reflective mirrorverse, as it were? M can see Maura in these reflections because it is the dead woman's former life, her body, she now inhabits, and the communication and link stem from there. Kind of like a ley line between life and death.

I don't know, it's just a little think piece of mine.

One deviation from 'Frankenstein' is that this story has a happy ending.


Spoilers end.


A few negatives about 'M Is for Monster' I've noticed, before I sign off:

Frances once says, near the beginning, that Maura never used to listen to her when she told her what to do... except it is a major point later that Maura used to always follow Frances and go along with her ideas and everything she did. In fact, the sisters had a lot in common, and loved science and talking, listening and learning from each other. Or does "since when do you [Maura] listen to me?" only apply to mundane things, like household chores, and getting out of bed in the morning, and not Maura being her older sister's guinea pig? It's not clear. Maybe it is meant to be a jokey line, I don't know.

Who is Asha? Does she live with the Ais' elderly neighbour, Dottie? Why? Who is she? Are Asha and Dottie a lesbian couple? It's not presented as such. Asha is barely in the comic, and she doesn't do anything. Why was she even included at all? She appears to be Indian, and the fact she is sidelined so carelessly - and given, like, one line, and no personality whatsoever - is problematic, even in a comic with Japanese main characters. Diversity should be carefully, thoughtfully implemented and all-encompassing.

I wish we could have explored M's sewing attraction and ambition more, and have gotten to know her as who she is as her own person. And could she also be nonbinary? That would have made the story and its LGBTQ+ themes even better.

And where are the sisters' parents? Are they dead too? They are only vaguely, offhandedly mentioned as part of flashbacks. Why don't they have anything to do with a storyline revolving around family loss and grief?

Lastly, the line in the blurb: 'Frances expects M to pursue the same path that Maura had been on—applying to college to become a scientist' - this is not in the comic itself. What college? Maura seemed way past college age, anyway, and she wasn't that much younger than the fully grown doctor Frances. Nowhere is anything like applying to college to become a scientist indicated. Either it is a lie, or someone in publishing seriously wasn't paying attention.

While I enjoyed 'M Is for Monster' less than, say, 'My Aunt Is a Monster', despite the former obviously, objectively being the superior graphic novel - the fun factor and personal tastes attribute to it - I still recommend it wholeheartedly. It is a wonderful debut.

Final Score: 3.5/5

Wednesday, 28 June 2023

Graphic Novel Review - 'Pumpkinheads' by Rainbow Rowell (Writer), Faith Erin Hicks (Artist)

Sometimes in life, you need a simple, romantic, funny, slice-of-life, slice-of-pie graphic novel that celebrates the autumnal season, and lasting relationships. And pumpkins.

I'd put off reading 'Pumpkinheads' for so long because it looked boring and trite to me, and I wasn't a big fan of either Rainbow Rowell or Faith Erin Hicks. I'd thought it would be extra boring if it were a prose novel. Even now I still think that. But as a graphic novel, with brilliant art that brightens, elevates and compliments the cute and funny story and characters, it becomes an irresistible tour de force.

The atmosphere and aesthetic of the whole comic is just *chef's kiss*. I love autumn, and pumpkins, and the colour orange, and delicious sweet foods. I'm British, and I've never been anywhere near a pumpkin patch that could double as a seasonal attraction theme park, and even I know they can't realistically be as big and as popular and raking in the money as the one presented in 'Pumpkinheads'. DeKnock's World Famous Pumpkin Patch & Autumn Jamboree is like Disneyland. But it looks great, and I wish it was real, and that's all the incentive I need to be sold on this graphic novel experience. Its "tackiness" has a budget behind it, and it is so darn endearing. I want to visit something like it so badly.

The two leads, Deja and Josiah - "seasonal best friends" happily working at the pumpkin patch, who are now on their last all-nighter shift before starting college - are instantly iconic. Irresistible, hilarious and warm, it is impossible not to adore them. Initially static, rule-following, blushing, geeky sweetheart and cinnamon bun Josiah is a book boyfriend for sure, and Deja - fat, Black, queer, spontaneous, impulsive, a comedienne, a foodie, has dated nearly every other employee at the patch, and is the best pal anyone could ask for - she is unforgettable. One of the best female characters I've ever seen in comics, period. The duo work amazingly well together. They play off of and compliment each other consistently, gradually, naturally, and adorably.

Basically the plot of 'Pumpkinheads' is Deja and Josiah sneaking out of their jobs on their last day to go in search of shy and nervous Josiah's three-year crush, who also works at the patch, and they stop for the different attractions along the way, but at the heart of everything is them and their relationship. It's wholesome, terrific, stupendous. While reading I didn't even care how they ended up together at the end of their mission/coming-of-age journey at the giant pumpkin patch theme park - whether they remain friends, or more, as predictable and trite as that is (why can't two people of opposite genders ever stay friends?!); it is that well written.

The other characters are single-or-double-scene cameos, for Deja and Josiah really are the stars, the important heart, of the book. Seeing as they're a great leading lady and man, I don't mind this a great deal.

Pumpkins, pumpkin spices, pumpkin pies, pumpkin bomb ice creams, corn, fudge, s'mores, succotash, gourds, caramel apples, a pumpkin-headed mascot, a petting zoo, a pony-go-round, a "haunted hacienda", a go-kart track, a train track, a corn maize maze, a hayrack ride, a runaway goat (in the background - Deja and Josiah never even see it - but it gets a satisfactory payoff), a child food thief, and a lot of bumping into exes - DeKnock's World Famous Pumpkin Patch & Autumn Jamboree, and 'Pumpkinheads', contains so much for something so seemingly simple, and "true to life".

It is an attraction I'd love to visit annually, seasonally - every autumn, every Halloween. Warm, tender, pleasant, cordial, cosy, sweet, it is a delicious delight.

Final Score: 4/5

Book Review - 'Tilda Tries Again' by Tom Percival

A nice, cute children's guide to depression. It is about persistence, perseverance, getting up, moving forward, and never giving up. Even when your world has been turned upside-down, and you feel it will never end and nothing will ever be back to normal again.

I found 'Tilda Tries Again' to be quite real, harrowing, and relatable to me, as an adult in her thirties. A lot of children can relate to it, as well. Anyone of any age can. It is short, simple, yet true to life.

A support system and being surrounded by people who care and comfort you are key, too.

I like the inclusion of a ladybird, too. And a redhaired heroine.

The colours are bright, striking and lovely.

Final Score: 4/5

Saturday, 24 June 2023

Graphic Novel Review - 'Northranger' by Rey Terciero (Writer), Bre Indigo (Artist)

'Northranger' - I wanted to give it a go after loving Rey Terciero's other works, 'Swan Lake: Quest for the Kingdoms' and 'Meg, Jo, Beth and Amy: A Modern Graphic Novel Retelling of Little Women', and because 'Northanger Abbey', of which this is a loose retelling, is the only Jane Austen novel I can say I like. It took a while - for it to be delivered to my house, and for me to finish it - and I'm glad to have finally read it. I'm glad it scared me--no, I wasn't scared of its horror movie references, themes and analyses, but it further opened my eyes, and it shocked me to see and understand how life - the world - can be limitlessly, senselessly cruel and dangerous to LBGTQ+ people, especially the youth, even in contemporary times.

When will the world learn to just accept humanity as it is? Accept how wonderfully diverse we all are? We are not all the same. We can't be. It's impossible. When will the old, outdated, out of touch, irrelevant (and let's tell it as we see it: mostly horrible, abusive, evil and desperate) privileged class/power in society learn to just grow up and face reality already?

'Northranger' can be sweet, but it is mostly heartbreaking. I can absolutely tell that Rey Terciero had drawn from some personal experiences in writing it. Similar to 'Flamer' by Mike Curato, it is so raw and real it hurts.

Every character is unforgettable, substantial, complex, and a force to be reckoned with, and certainly not all of them are likeable. The creepy, intense, mystery-driven, brown and black and white graphic novel (I love the art, and the characters' expressions) is a true coming-of-age teen LBGTQ story; no plot, just a messy, up-and-down, hot-and-cold, beautiful and scary life experience.

For horror films, and haunted houses, are nothing compared to how scary the real world is.

And how complicated and secretive families can be.

'Northranger' - I'm keeping my review on it short, as I shan't dare reveal anything spoiler-y, in the hope that others will want to read it and experience it blind, creeped out, shocked, saddened, and intrigued by its mysteries themselves. It could have had more in its romance element - I'll be honest, I wasn't quite feeling it between the two leads - plus not everything is resolved by the end (but hey, that is real life, right? What end?), and I can't stand how awful, ignorant, thoughtless and selfish some of the adults are, to children, and to their children, even the adults who don't really mean to be bigoted. They could have been held accountable further, with deeper realising, I believe. Content warning for domestic violence and abuse, as well as homophobia and racism.

Dementia is another theme in the story that is handled well. Also toxic masculinity. Then there's depression, mental and emotional health.

I don't like most of the films and TV shows that are praised uncritically by the young characters in 'Northranger'. I mean, seriously - 'Buffy'? Coppola's 'Bram Stoker's Dracula'? 'Sixteen Candles'!? In a book like this!? But once in a blue moon it shares my tastes, in accolading 'Interview with a Vampire', 'Jennifer's Body', 'A Girl Walks Home Alone at Night', and 'Love, Simon' (though how has the main character never heard of that film until he is shown it on DVD? And dude: read books as well as watch movies).

I still don't like horror movies - not usually, not the conventional kind. I may not understand some people's love for them, but that doesn't mean I don't want to listen and try to understand should they explain why they love them, and why they would mean so much to them, in their lives. I won't dismiss the films, just because they're not for me. I won't dismiss an entire genre of film - one of the oldest, and one of the oldest forms of storytelling in humankind's story-loving history - like too many people remain determined to dismiss an entire community, groups of people, for existing.

Hate crime is hate crime.

Bigots, I will say it again: grow up, listen, look around you, stop being stubborn (9 times out of 10 you're not afraid of change, you're being arseholes for the sake of it), get out of your little bubble (and your head out of your arse), and get your act together already.

You are killing children - the youth, future generations - with your ignorance and fearmongering. Stop it now.

Final Score: 3.5/5

Graphic Novel Review - 'DeadEndia: The Watcher's Test' by Hamish Steele

2026 REREAD: I'm glad to have read this dark, Halloween-y, funny, cartoony delight again.

'DeadEndia' is very different from the animated series, 'Dead End: Paranormal Park', but that is not a bad thing. Both versions of the story and characters are super entertaining, and full of passion, humour and heart.

However, the comic is a little scatterbrained and erratic, with a few forgotten characters along the fast-paced, freight train track that is the plot progression. But like with the cartoon, I can only look back on it with great fondness.

I think I will read the rest of the series - the rest of the graphic novel trilogy - to see more of these characters, and to see how 'DeadEndia' truly does end(ia) (I did that bad pun in my original review, deadn't I?). It will fill the gap left in my heart after the cartoon was cancelled, at any rate (#&*%! you to every level and plane of hell and heaven there is, Netflix - I'm glad to have cancelled you).

This is a wonderful, inclusive, LBGTQ+, broad, epic fantasy horror comedy comic and toon, and franchise.

Bless you, Hamish Steele.

Final Score: 3.5/5





Original Review:



I've wanted to read this ever since seeing and loving the TV series (though I've yet to see the second season, once I'm back on Netflix), and... wow.

'DeadEndia' has some similarities, with some of the same aesthetics, but it is mostly very different from the animated adaptation, 'Dead End: Paranormal Park'. One main thing to take away from the comic is that, unlike the TV show, it is definitely not for children. More "edginess" and darkness and horror aside, I certainly did not expect the iconic cartoon hero, the trans, gay Jewish boy Barney Guttman, to have family issues so bad that he was once... suicidal. I don't want to reveal anything potentially triggering, but holy shit his backstory is dark. The autistic icon Norma Khan being more cynical and having a tragic dead parent past, with an older sister, is also something I did not expect.

There were a hell of a lot of things that shocked me when coming into 'DeadEndia'. It is horror and comedy at its core. It embraces it; and all the while it flows, together with a creative, cartoony, colourful, eclectic, wild and wacky messiness - and I commend every daring thing it puts out there, and not just for its LBGTQ+, POC, neurodivergent and mental health rep.

So I do recommend 'DeadEndia: The Watcher's Test' if you're already a fan of 'Dead End: Paranormal Park'. Only make sure you're in a good, healthy headspace and safe space beforehand. You may be in for a shocking treat, deep and dark, but additionally funny in a gallows humour way, that is worth it in the end(ia). There is the undeniably strong - raw - human, relatable and emotional element to it, as well; it is intense all around. This undoubtably contributes to the lasting impact and development of Hamish Steele's genius creation.

Last, spoiler-free notes: Pauline Phoenix is a hilarious celebrity parody icon (I keep using that word in this review, don't I?), Pugsley the doggie is a cute and funny (and tragic) mascot, Badyah is such a sweet little psycho without a care in the world, and Courtney remains one of my favourite demons ever, alongside Calcifer from 'Howl's Moving Castle' and Hooty from 'The Owl House'. She/they is/are a precious, funny, adorable, spirited, creepy, complex and evil-ish concept. In fact, 'Dead Endia' does "evil", flawed, imperfect, messy, and/or morally grey characters right.

An awesome, scary, silly, humorous, magical, demonic, passionate, and truly revolutionary and inclusive comic and cartoon.

Final Score: 4/5