'Please Be My Star' is a gender-bent version of 'The Phantom of the Opera' set in a modern day American high school. Its main themes are isolation, obsession, depression, social anxiety, self-image, self-esteem, creativity, theatre, geek culture, taking part in groups and making new friends, stress, "happily ever afters", and finding yourself and your self-confidence.
Sure, despite its "realism", it is overall a wish-fulfilment fantasy, and kind of problematic - in that angle where if it was deconstructed and the genders in canon were reversed, it would easily be a horror, not a romance; a psychological thriller genre story (so in other words, like pretty much every classic, John Hughes-esque romcom ever made).But you know what? Why shouldn't insecure, weird, unpopular girls who are not conventionally attractive get their own wish-fulfilment fantasy as well? Why shouldn't geek girls like hot guys, and in their own weird way?Even though the female protagonist in 'Please Be My Star' is rather stalkerish, she's not hurting anyone, and her coming-of-age story is ultimately about her loving herself for who she is, and expressing and understanding herself in her writing, regardless of what anyone thinks, before she can properly love and pursue anyone else.'Please Be My Star' can come across as tonally all over the place, in that it seems to want to be a YA depression piece about an outcast teenage girl who is a creepy stalker with a crush, and is creative, and wants to love herself and feel worthy of others' love, but she can't bring herself to believe this in a society that is obsessed with looks... and perhaps she is little too overimaginative, such as in her writing... but at the end of the day, it is a lighthearted, cute manifesto to all the weirdo (albeit cishet white) girls in the world, dying for a YA story like this. Like, you go girl! Go big or go home, girl!So don't go into it expecting something like an actual 'The Phantom of the Opera' adaptation, or the films 'Carrie' and 'May'.It's not a psychological thriller after all.It is both a cry for help and a story of hope.For a better world for weirdos.I know I personally relate to the main character, Erika Early, especially when I was younger - brown hair, imaginative, a lonely, self-conscious, self-talking, friendless social outcast, and a creative writer. I wasn't quite as obsessive as she is when I was a teenager - I certainly never built a shrine to anyone or collected stuff belonging to other people for the purpose of said shrine (I had my limits; I was self-conscious enough to try not to be creepy, or maybe I simply didn't like most other people and was too self-absorbed in my own crap) - but I know what it's like to dare, or not dare, to have crushes on guys who are so far out of my league that we might as well be from different planets. Practically everybody was shallow, superficial, and obsessed with popularity, fitting in and being "normal", and therefore I never bothered to pursue any crush, out of fear of rejection and humiliation. "Fitting in" didn't come naturally to me and it wasn't as effortless as others made it seem. It was truly hopeless.I consider Erika to be braver than I am. She at least tries to get her crush involved in her life, and maybe get him to like her back, against all unlikely odds.I also relate to her school theatre group experiences. Theatre was one of the few creative and social pursuits I tried at, in expressing myself. Those rehearsals, my good, grief goddesses.Christian Dominguez, Erika's love interest, is a cute, sweet, cool, handsome boy - funny, thoughtful, warm, considerate, and seemingly perfect. However, the comic reveals his family life, and how he isn't as much of a one-dimensional, gorgeous dream boy as he first appears. Like Erika, he's complex, and has issues, like all humans.In conclusion: not such a wish-fulfilment fantasy how many times have I used that phrase in this review.Though it still is one.Kinda?It's just... 'Please Be My Star' is a profoundly personal hard-hitter for me. It criticises, and sympathises with, and helps, and uplifts weirdo geek girls who are not good at interacting with people. It gives them hope. And a hug.It is their love letter. Not necessarily their validation for existing (they don't need it), nor their enabler in problematic behaviour.For "unattractive", "creepy" and "freak" girls deserve love, too.
On top of all that, it feels like an additional love letter to shōjo manga.
I admit that, among its flaws, 'Please Be My Star' is geek girl representation - complete with notebooks on their real people crushes and their fictional crushes, including in cartoons and video games, I can relate! - from a cishet-normative perspective. Though there is that one-off moment where two lesbians are included in Erika's "Forever Boys" book, and she states, "Gender is irrelevant. A boy is a state of mind." (It's supposed to be complicated?) Em, anyway, the comic's LBGTQA+ rep is relegated to its side characters (Julie and Morgan are great, and funny), which is head-tilting and dated for a 2024 graphic novel.
But darn it, it is a sweet, lovely gesture of a book from an underdog female perspective, ya know? It also loves theatre, writing, acting, and costume making, and record players, vintage bands, CDs, VHS tapes, classic movies, classic actors, and typewriters. Retro! Plus playlists, comics and manga. And I love the (somewhat ambiguous?) ending.
So there you have it: my review of 'Please Be My Star', one of my guilty pleasures of 2025.
Let me have this, hmm'kay? And it is a lot deeper, and cleverer, and more self-aware, insightful and introspective than you might think.
Everyone is messy.
It is impossible to have it all together, all the time.
Few have the courage to admit they always will be a mess.
And that's okay.
Messy is okay.
You will be loved, and you are loved, for your imperfections, your "defects", anyway.
You'll see.
Erika - and me, and everybody else - I love you all.
Final Score: 3.5/5