'Helen of Wyndhorn' has the workings of a comics classic, and a coveted collectable. It has a brilliant concept, and I enjoyed it, even if I still can't figure out every layer of its story, or what the Hel(en) even happened in it.
To go back to the book's title, Wyndhorn is the mansion home of the Coles, that loses its importance at the very end and in the scenes set after the 1930s. Like, it is forgotten about by everyone.
Seriously, what happened to it? Is no one living there at present? Has no one thought to investigate it?
But I won't reveal anymore due to spoilers.
Although, which plot holes are intentional and which are not in this story-within-a-story?
Is it really anti-violence? Anti-violence-as-escape? To judge the ending, probably. In addition, its fantasy world looks tremendous, but is rather one-dimensional, seemingly filled to the brim with kill-or-be-killed monsters, and savage-to-neutral gods.
Who in Helen's name is the "pirate queen" Sarra, too? Is she just a character from Helen's father's stories? And what about the "Better than Shakespeare" inscription engraved on his tombstone, told to us at the beginning? It's presented as important then, only it doesn't come up again.
Is C.K. Cole's 'Othan' series a novel series or a comic series? Is it both? Is this to do with how pulp fiction works?
Is the whole thing a looping tragedy? Surely there is hope, after all?
BUT .
Regardless of any convolution and confusion, 'Helen of Wyndhorn' contains swords and sorcery (and axes), fantasy novel themes that are deconstructed, fantasy creatures (including a cute little one, a "flyune", called No, amusingly), a highly unconventional heroine in Helen (and Lilith, as well), the mother-and-daughter bond between Helen and Lilith, the main theme of grief - it is all about grief, and what it does to people, and the lengths they go to escape it, rather than confront it - and generational trauma, and utterly fantastic artwork. It has a bit of everything, including a gothic ambiance, a redheaded heroine, talk of the power of fantasy, and LBGTQ rep. So it receives a yes! recommendation from me.
It is like 'Conan the Barbarian' meets 'Amethyst: Princess of Gemworld' meets 'Pan's Labyrinth' meets 'The Boy and the Heron' meets 'Watchmen'. I am surprised by how much I like it, since I am definitely not a fan of Tom King's works. But 'Helen of Wyndhorn', no matter how weird, complex, multilayered, and ambiguous it gets, it isn't pretentious, and it isn't too wordy, like a novel. Well, okay, it is, but it isn't too annoying, and it isn't to the detriment of the overall, standalone comic. The narration and dialogue aid the story, and flow with it, rather than distract from it, and bloat it.
To conclude, while I wouldn't call 'Helen of Wyndhorn' a perfectly written masterpiece of fiction, it is well written - and well drawn - ambition that is splashed, slashed and dashed wonderfully and excitingly in comic book form. It is something to be read again and again, to be understood better (or not) each time.
Who says that a well educated lady can't be a physically fit fighter, too, in more ways than one? She'll need her family, to support her, love her, and talk to her.
Final Score: 3.5/5